Chủ Nhật, 2 tháng 10, 2005

Is Repeal of the Estate Tax a Dead Issue?

Sometime shortly, the Senate is expected to vote on the fate of the estate tax. The House has already voted to repeal the tax; however, several Senators have found it difficult to vote for total repeal. One Senator, Ron Wyden (D-Ore.), who has voted to repeal the estate tax in the past, recently noted, “The deficit picture is different today and the choices are pretty darn hard.”

The budget deficit has been dramatically increased in the past year, with two major hurricanes costing hundreds of billions in recovery costs, and a war in Iraq that continues to demand billions of dollars to prosecute. Further, Congress will be facing votes this fall on measures to institute cuts in a range of domestic programs. The trade-offs associated with repealing or dramatically curtailing the estate tax are becoming more evident than they were in the recent past.

The Senate voted on legislation to repeal the estate tax every year from 1999 through 2002. At the time of each of those votes, the Congressional Budget Office was projecting sizeable surpluses over the coming ten-year budget period. The current fiscal picture is very different. CBO now forecasts large deficits over the next 10 years and beyond.It is particularly telling to compare the present outlook with the outlook at the time that Congress debated the 2001 tax-cut package, which included the measure that repeals the estate tax in 2010. In 2001, CBO was projecting a surplus of $5.6 trillion over the 2002-2011 period. Today, deficits of $3.7 trillion are projected over that period.

The coming estate tax vote also differs from earlier votes in that it is occurring amidst a debate on how to restore long-term solvency to Social Security. Eliminating or dramatically shrinking the estate tax would take “off the table” a source of revenue that could be used to help close the Social Security shortfall. Some Social Security proposals, such as a plan developed by former Social Security Commissioner Robert Ball, would help restore solvency by maintaining a moderate-size estate tax and dedicating the revenues it collects to Social Security. (The Ball plan combines this measure with changes in Social Security benefits and taxes.) Eliminating most or all of the estate tax would eliminate this option, however, and thereby increase the depth of the Social Security benefit cuts or payroll tax increases that ultimately will be needed to restore solvency.

As you are probably aware, the current exemption against estate tax is $1.5 million per person. That exemption, unless the law is changed, will increase to $2 million per person over the next three years, then go to $3.5 million in 2009, disappear entirely in 2010, and drop back to $1 million per person in 2011. It is my personal belief, based on information coming out of Congress, the most likely scenario will be that with increased pressure on Congress to maintain revenue, at least presently, that estate tax repeal is dead in the water for the next few years. Instead, I anticipate that Congress will ultimately raise the exemption to around $4 - $5 million per person and lower the effective tax rate from a top rate of around 50% to something in the 25% range.

The bottom line is that your estate planning should be based on the assumption that the estate tax will not be repealed. Better to plan for the tax and be wrong than to plan for the repeal and be wrong.

Thứ Sáu, 23 tháng 9, 2005

Waiting Out Hurricane Rita

As you know, the Houston and Southeast Texas area are hunkering down for what is right now a Category 3 hurricane. In light of that, my office has been closed for the last two days so that families could evacute out of Houston (which, if you have watched news reports, was probably the single largest evacuation in U.S. history).

While my wife and children have left for the Austin area, I am staying in Houston, trying to secure property and keep an eye on my property and my in-law's property. Keep all of Houston and the area east of us to Beaumont in your thoughts and prayers.

Once things are back to normal, we hope to be posting again. Godspeed to everyone.

Thứ Hai, 12 tháng 9, 2005

Answers to Readers' Questions

I apologize for not having updated the blog earlier, but I hit an extremely busy stretch there for three weeks and so I had no real free time to update the site. In the meantime, I have received some emails from various persons that I thought I would share with you. If you have a question you would like to see answered here, send me an email by clicking here.


My father recently died in California. He was a resident there but also had some real estate and a bank account in South Texas. He did not have a Will. Do we have to do anything in a Texas court regarding probate?

Unfortunately not only will you have to have a determination as to heirship in California, you will also have to initiate an heirship determination proceeding in the Texas county where the real property is located. California law will govern all the real estate in that state, plus all the non-real estate assets in other states, but Texas law governs as to any real property located here. If he had a Will, you could have just filed an “exemplified copy” of the Will and the Order Admitting the Will to Probate in the deed records of Texas county where the property is located. An exemplified copy is similar to a certified copy, except that the clerk of the court has to verify and attest that the signature of the Judge on the probate order is true and correct.

Since there is no Will, an heirship determination must be held in Texas. The court will appoint an attorney ad litem to represent any minor or missing/unknown heirs. Testimony will have to be given as to the family history of your father by two disinterested witnesses who were familiar with the family history. If there is no one in Texas who can give that testimony, you will likely have to get the written deposition of two witnesses in California who can provide this testimony. Once the heirship is complete, title in the Texas property will vest in the proper heirs. Texas Probate Code Section 38 lists the persons who would receive this property on the death of someone without a Will.

I have family who is coming over from Louisiana following Hurricane Katrina, and they plan on staying in Texas permanently. I was wondering whether they needed to execute a new Will, or whether their current Wills were sufficient.

First of all, let me just say that we all wish all the best to your family and all others who are suffering the effects of this devastating storm. Normally I would say that it is not usually necessary for someone who is moving from another state to Texas to have to change their Wills, because Texas probate courts give full credit to any Will executed in another state. However, Louisiana uses the old Napoleonic Code when it comes to estates, and while certain changes have been made recently that eases some of the unusual provisions that are not found in a lot of other states, the way Wills are still required to be written (especially those written prior to some of the recent law revisions) seem to baffle many non-Louisiana probate attorneys. Thus, it might be best to suggest to them that they make the change whenever they get settled in and adjusted to their new life here in Texas. Best of luck to them.

My husband is in the hospital and wants a new Will. He has lost use of his arms, though, and can’t sign anything. Can I sign the Will for him?

Although you don’t say it specifically, I assume that your husband is mentally competent and has the ability to understand what is being put into his new Will. If that is the case, then he can direct that someone else sign for him, but it must be done in his presence and at his direction, and in the presence of the witnesses. Note that you cannot guide his hand in signing if he did not ask you to do that. Make sure that in the presence of the witnesses, he clearly states his desire for you to sign the Will for him. Section 59 of the Texas Probate Code provides the requirements for the execution of a Will.

Thứ Ba, 23 tháng 8, 2005

The Living Trust Fallacy in Texas

I constantly receive calls from existing and potential clients about “living trusts” and how they have heard someone talking about how much they need one. My response to most of these people is to ask them a simple question: Why do YOU need one? It is almost inevitable that I get the same answer—“to avoid probate.” When I hear that, I almost have to cringe, because the reality is that in Texas, there is not the need to avoid probate.

Texas has an administration process that is probably the simplest in the nation. It is known as "independent administration", and it means that other than proving the Will is valid, the appointment of an executor, and the filing with the probate court of an inventory of the assets that actually pass under the Will, there is no court involvement in the administration of the estate. The executor handles all matters independent of court supervision, and needs no approval from the Court to sell property, distribute assets, pay expenses, or do anything else that might arise in the regular administration of an estate. This saves time and money, since there is no necessity to go to the Court (incurring legal expenses) for approval of anything the executor needs to get done. Therefore, in Texas, delays or prohibitive costs of probate are not as much of a concern as they are in many states, the way they might be in California, New York or Florida.

Here are some other fallacies about living trusts in Texas:

1. The Estate Tax Savings Fallacy. One of the “big lies” that I often hear about revocable living trusts is that it will help the Grantor (i.e., the person creating the trust) save on taxes. How does it do that? The living trust contains a “bypass trust” to hold the Grantor’s exemption against estate tax upon the Grantor’s death for the benefit of the Grantor’s surviving spouse. This “bypass trust” is the same type of trust that is utilized in Wills all the time. In other words, it is not saving any additional taxes that you would not have saved by using the same type of trust in the Last Will and Testament. Further, if the Grantor is not married, a living trust cannot save anything from an estate tax standpoint. Every asset held by the living trust will be subject to inclusion in the estate of the Grantor, so there is no “tax savings” by transferring assets to a revocable trust by a single person.

2. The Creditor Protection Fallacy. It also cannot protect you from creditor claims (another fallacy that trust salespeople trumpet). Transferring the assets to a revocable trust (at least in Texas) means that the Grantor still has the power to get to the assets at any time. Even if there is an independent trustee, the fact that the trust is revocable means that the Grantor can terminate the trust and have the assets returned at any time. Texas law provides if the Grantor has full access to trust assets, then creditors have that same access.


3. The Cost Savings Fallacy. Because living trusts can (in some cases) be more complicated than wills, they typically cost more. There is also the necessity to transfer title to property (which requires deeds and other title transfer documents), which, if the attorney prepares, adds to the costs. Many times property does not wind up getting transferred to the trust, and you have to probate the Decedent’s Will anyway. If the Decedent had a pour-over will -- a will that says that everything owned by the Decedent flows into the living trust, the administration of the estate would be fairly straightforward and possibly reduce the probate costs. However, I have found that I can typically prepare the Will, and then probate and administer an estate where there is no living trust for the same or less cost than to prepare the trust and transfer all the assets to the trust. To me, the cost savings issue is not that great. However, I am speaking as a Texas attorney, and this likely would not hold true in California or New York.

The only times when I have found utilizing a living trust is a good idea is under the following circumstances:

Real estate in another state -- If you are a Texas resident and own real estate in another state, utilizing a living trust would eliminate the necessity of having to go through a probate proceeding in that state.

Incapacity issues – If you are concerned about incapacity (e.g., you have a history of Alzheimer’s Disease in your family), perhaps a living trust could be utilized to provide for the management of your assets in the event of your incapacity, especially if you have no close friends or family members who would act on your behalf. In that case you might need a professional trustee to manage your assets for you. On the other hand, of you have family members that you trust to manage your assets, a simpler method of the continuing management of the assets would not be a living trust, but general power of attorney naming an agent to handle financial matters for you in the event of your incapacity.

Will contest likely -- If your loved ones are likely to fight over your will, then in some cases (with expert advice and attention) a living trust may make it less likely that someone will successfully contest your plan based on undue influence, lack of capacity, etc.

Many (if not all) of the above situations may not be relevant to you. Thus, a living trust likely is not a viable estate planning alternative if you are a Texas resident. Utilizing a Will, a general power of attorney, a medical power of attorney and a directive to physicians is still likely to be the most estate planning you will ever need. However, as always, you should consult with a competent attorney who practices in the estate planning area to help you make that determination.

Thứ Ba, 16 tháng 8, 2005

Alternatives to Probate Administration for Small Estates in Texas

There are times when the full administration of an estate does not make much sense. For example, what if there is only a couple of assets of the estate, such as a house and a bank account, both of which were solely in the name of the Decedent? The bank account only has about $1000 in it. Do you still have to open an administration of the estate for the sole purpose of collecting the bank account and transferring title to the homestead?

In Texas, there are two alternatives to the administration process; one where there was a Will, and one where the Decedent died intestate (i.e., without a Will). The first alternative is known as the collection of small estates upon affidavit, provided for in Texas Probate Code Sections 137 and 138.

If the Decedent had no Will, and the total value of the estate, not counting the value of the house and other exempt property, was less than $50,000, then you can file an affidavit with the probate court of proper jurisdiction (i.e., in the county where the Decedent was a resident), stating who the proper heirs of the estate would be, using the heirship rules of Texas Probate Code Section 38. Two disinterested witnesses have to swear to the heirship information contained in the affidavit. The small estate affidavit rout is very inexpensive (the filing cost in most counties is less than $75) and in many cases can be done without the involvement of an attorney.

Upon approval of the affidavit by the probate court, all persons or entities dealing with distributees of assets from the small estate are released to the same extent as if they dealt with a personal representative of the estate. Distributees can bring action to force delivery of the estate property and the distributees will be liable to any creditors or anyone else having a prior right to the property. You should note that this procedure does not transfer title to real property, except for a homestead. Thus, if the Decedent owned real property other than the homestead, and had no Will, probably your only alternative is to proceed with a determination of heirship proceeding.

A small estate affidavit usually works well with some assets, such as bank accounts, titles to automobiles, savings bonds and the homestead, but it is usually difficult, if not impossible, to use the affidavit to transfer title to publicly traded stocks and bonds, partnership accounts or brokerage accounts in general. Why? Because most publicly traded stocks and bonds are handled by transfer agents who are located in New York or Chicago, and the people working for these transfer agents rarely deal with small estate affidavits for the transfer of title. They are much more comfortable working with letters testamentary and usually will demand letters before they will transfer the title. With all the trouble it takes to get an order from the court ordering the transfer agent to transfer the stock or bond, you might be better off just going through the administration process to begin with.

What if the Decedent had a Will but few assets, or assets that do not require a lot of work in transferring—all the holder of the asset needs is an order from the court and perhaps a copy of the Will? If there is no need for an administration of the estate, then the Will can be probated as a muniment of title only, as provided in Texas Probate Code Sections 89A through 89C.

This procedure will only be allowed by the court when the applicant can show that (1) the estate has no unpaid debts, excluding debts secured by liens on real estate, and (2) there is no necessity for administration. The will must still be proved valid at a hearing before the court; however, no executor will be appointed. In probating a Will as a muniment of title, it is suggested you utilize an attorney because it is more complex than the simple filing of the small estate affidavit.

The effect of an order admitting a will to probate as a muniment of title is strong in that it is legal authority to all persons (1) owing any money to the deceased; (2) having custody of any property of the deceased; (3) acting as registrar or transfer agent of any evidence of interest, indebtedness, property, or right belonging to the estate; or (4) purchasing from or otherwise dealing with the estate, for payment or transfer to the person named in the will as entitled to receive the particular asset, without any administration. In other words, after the will is admitted to probate as a muniment of title, the beneficiaries of the decedent's estate become the owners of the property outright.

Again, if you are dealing with stocks and bonds, and a transfer agent will only accept letters testamentary rather than an order from a court certified that the beneficiaries in the Will are the only distributees of the estate, then you may not be able to utilize the muniment of title process. In addition, if there are numerous debts of the estate, an administration is the only alternative.

In any event, it is not necessary to create an administration in every instance in Texas, and for those estates with simple assets, the small estate affidavit or muniment of title route may be the way to go. Before pursuing those particular avenues, you should obviously consult with a reputable attorney who practices in this area to determine whether either of these options would be suitable for your situation.

Thứ Tư, 10 tháng 8, 2005

Planning for Domestic Partners

It was a nice trip to Colorado this past week, one of the most beautiful states you can travel to during the summertime. I highly recommend a whitewater rafting trip such as the one we took down the Colorado River, which provided us some of the most majestic scenes you will ever see in the U.S.

One of the things that I encountered in Colorado during my stay at the Broadmoor in Colorado Springs was a gay couple who overheard me speaking to someone about estate planning. One of the ladies asked what would happen to her assets if she died without a Will. After asking a few questions about children (none), potential marriage in a state that allowed for gay marriage or civil unions (no intent) and assets (mostly cash and real estate in her name), I had to inform her that without a Will, most of her assets would pass according to the intestacy laws of her home state, which meant that her partner would wind up with none of the probate assets.

If you have a domestic partner, gay or straight, you are more of a candidate for a Will and basic estate planning than even married couples or a single person with children. Why? Because most (if not all) states’ intestacy laws do not account for domestic partners. You are treated as if you died single regardless of what you consider yourself in your relationship. A married person in Texas who dies without a Will usually winds having all his property (assuming it is community property) passing to his surviving spouse, so the danger of not having a Will is less extreme for that person.

Another tricky scenario—what if the person who died had a child, and the natural surviving parent of the child was unknown (e.g., the child was adopted or the child was the product of in vitro fertilization? Who would be named as the guardian of the child? The law in Texas provides a laundry list of persons entitled to be named, starting with the surviving parent, then grandparents, then siblings, and so on, but there is no mention of a domestic partner. If a sibling of the decedent asserts a claim to be guardian, it could result in a very costly court battle. A Will and/or a Designation of Guardian in Advance of Need could eliminate this problem.

Two other situations also present themselves: Incapacity in general and incapacity for medical purposes. If a domestic partner becomes incapacitated, the law in Texas does not provide for the incapacitated’s partner to be appointed Guardian of the person or estate. Nor does it provide for a partner to be able to make medical decisions on behalf of the incapacitated person. These could be resolved easily through a general power of attorney and medical power of attorney in favor of the partner.

Finally, don’t forget about non-probate assets when planning for a domestic partner. Any beneficiary designations on an IRA, life insurance policy, annuity, or employee benefit plans should be updated to reflect the partner as the primary beneficiary (if that is desired). Other miscellaneous items to also remember are things such as putting the partner as a signor on the safety deposit box or providing for a joint bank account, and providing for a partner to have the right to dispose of the body either by cremation or burial on their partner’s death.

Thứ Sáu, 29 tháng 7, 2005

Some Time Off and Some Problems Revisited

I am taking a much needed vacation beginning July 30th and heading to what I hope are the much cooler climates of Colorado for a week. I will not be posting anything in the meantime; however, before I took off, I wanted to share a couple of problems which came across my desk this past week which serve as warning signs to people who are doing their Wills. Both of these were prepared and executed by people on their own without legal counsel.

The first was a Will that by and large was correct in the body of the Will. However, when it came to the signatures, I found a problem. In Texas, a typewritten Will (which this was), has to signed by the Testator and witnessed by two individuals above the age of 14. Texas also has a provision where the Testator and the witnesses can sign what is known as a "self-proving affidavit," which allows the Will to be probated without the necessity of the witnesses having to come to court and give testimony that they were present when the Testator signed the Will, that the Testator was above the age of 18 and of sound mind, etc.

Unfortunately in this situation, the Testator signed the Will and the self-proving affidavit, but the witnesses only signed the affidavit--there were not even any signature lines for the witnesses on the Will (I will add here that the Testator who prepared the Will was a patent attorney, which only goes to prove that lawyers are there own worst clients). Prior to 1991, this would have rendered the Will completely invalid. Fortunately, Section 59 of the Texas Probate Code was changed in 1991 to provide that in this type of situation, the witnesses' signature to the affidavit will be considered a signature to the Will if necessary to prove that the Will was signed by the Testator, but the Will can no longer be considered self-proven, meaning that either one or both of the witnesses to the affidavit will have to give testimony in court as to the execution of the Will, or two witnesses will be needed to prove up the Testator's handwriting. Moral: Make sure that you have the Testator and the witnesses sign not only the Will, but also the self-proving affidavit. Added notes: make sure the witnesses are over the age of 14, and not related to the Testator or a beneficiary under the Will.

Second problem I encountered:

A gentlemen died with an estate of approximately $2 million. His son brought me the Will, which had been prepared by his father, using forms he had cobbled together from form books and other people's Wills, apparently. Dad's first wife had died and he subsequently remarried, so he wanted to make some provisions for the second wife, who did not get along at all with Dad's children. Dad started out by making some specific bequests worth about $250,000 to his children. In the following Article, he leaves "all my remaining property in trust for my wife for her lifetime." The rest of the Article provides the terms of the trust, which on termination was to be paid to her estate (note: doing this would certainly cut his children off from this share of his estate, since it is very unlikely she would leave any of this property to Dad's children).

The next Article is where things get unusual. He provides that he leaves "all the rest and remainder of my property to my children in equal shares." He now has created, in effect, two residuary clauses leaving all his property in very different ways. It is painfully obvious that he had no idea what he had written and the amount of conflict and confusion that would cause. It is now unclear who receives the residuary estate, so we are going to have to file what is known in Texas as a Petition for Declaratory Judgment with the probate court to have the court determine who the proper recipient of the residuary estate will be. Sometimes, in a case like this, you could go back to the attorney who drafted it and ask: What happened here? What did you mean? What do your notes say? Such extrinsic evidence would normally be admissable if the intent cannot be gleaned from the plain reading of the Will. However, in this case, the drafter of the Will was the Testator, and his intent died with him, so we will have to resort to other means to determine the ultimate beneficiaries. Moral: Don't be penny wise and pound foolish when it comes to drafting such an important document such as your Will. Get competent legal counsel to help in drafting your documents--and don't forget to read what they have drafted! Ask questions--what does this mean? Show me where the Articles where the property gets distributed. What happens is this person does not survive me? You've worked hard to acquire your assets. Don't inhibit your plans for these assets with second-rate software where you can draft your own Wills or with attorneys whose speciality is not in the estate planning area.

Bài đăng phổ biến